A drop and swap 1031 is a two-step restructuring in which a partnership or multi-member LLC deeds its property to its members as tenants in common (the drop), and each member then sells his or her own undivided interest and decides alone whether to complete a 1031 exchange (the swap). It solves a common split, where one partner wants cash and another wants to keep deferring the tax into NNN income, because an interest in a partnership is not real property under Treas. Reg. 1.1031(a)-3 and cannot be exchanged. No statute sets how long the co-owners must hold their deeded interests before the sale, and each co-owner who exchanges runs his or her own 45-day and 180-day deadlines.
The general rules of a forward exchange are covered in our 1031 exchange guide.
Why can’t LLC partners go separate ways in a 1031 exchange?
LLC partners cannot go separate ways in a 1031 exchange because a multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership by default, so the LLC itself is the seller and the taxpayer that must buy the replacement property. A member’s interest in that LLC is not real property, so no member can exchange his or her share alone.
Under the same taxpayer rule, the entity that sells must be the entity that buys, and Treas. Reg. 301.7701-3(b)(1) classifies a domestic LLC with two or more members as a partnership unless it elects otherwise.
In Chapter 6, 1031 Exchange, of The NNN Triple Net Property Book, Alan Fruitman writes, “When business partners want a ‘divorce’ and own property in one LLC, it is very messy, not to mention taxing, if they do not do a 1031 exchange.” Alan explains that when one LLC sells, that same LLC must buy the replacement property, so owners inside one LLC have to exchange together.
A typical version looks like this. Two partners have owned an 18-unit apartment building in one LLC for 14 years. One partner, close to retirement, wants cash to pay off a home and fund other plans. The other wants to stop managing tenants and move his half into a single-tenant NNN property with a corporate lease, with the tax still deferred.
What happens if the LLC sells and pays the departing partner in cash?
If the LLC sells, exchanges part of the proceeds and pays the departing partner in cash, the partnership has completed a partial exchange, and the cash is taxable boot to the partnership. The resulting gain is allocated among all partners under the operating agreement, so the partner who stays can owe tax on cash he never received.
Allocating all of that gain to the departing partner is a special allocation, and it must have substantial economic effect under Section 704(b) to hold up. How boot is measured and taxed is explained in our posts on 1031 exchange boot and the partial 1031 exchange. The drop and swap avoids the problem by moving the exchange decision from the partnership to each owner before the sale.
How does a drop and swap work, step by step?
A drop and swap works in two stages. First, the partnership distributes undivided tenancy-in-common deeds to its members in proportion to their interests, usually into each member’s own single-member LLC. Then the co-owners sign the sale contract as sellers, and each co-owner who exchanges runs a separate 1031 exchange with a qualified intermediary.
The steps below follow the order that practitioner checklists generally use:
- Before the property is listed, the partners agree in writing to distribute the property and confirm that the operating agreement allows a distribution in kind.
- The partners’ CPA and attorney check whether any partner contributed the property in the last seven years, how the loan will split among the co-owners, and how the state where the property sits treats the transaction.
- The lender approves the transfer, because a deed out of the borrowing LLC can trigger the loan’s due-on-transfer clause.
- The LLC records a deed conveying an undivided interest to each member’s single-member LLC, and the co-owners file any transfer tax returns that the state or county requires.
- The co-owners sign a tenancy-in-common agreement, open separate bank accounts, take rent in proportion to their interests and notify the tenants of the new owners.
- The co-owners, not the LLC, sign the listing agreement and the purchase contract as sellers.
- Before closing, each co-owner who exchanges signs a separate exchange agreement with a qualified intermediary, and the co-owner who wants cash takes his or her share of the proceeds at closing.
- The partnership answers yes to the Form 1065 question on distributing undivided interests, each partner who received property files Form 7217, and each co-owner reports his or her own sale or exchange.
The drop changes who the seller is on every document that matters, as the comparison below shows.
| Item |
Before the Drop |
After the Drop |
| Title |
The LLC |
Each member’s single-member LLC, as tenants in common |
| Seller for tax purposes |
The partnership |
Each co-owner, through a disregarded LLC |
| Purchase contract signed by |
The LLC |
Each co-owner |
| Rent and expenses |
One LLC account |
Each co-owner‘s account, in proportion to ownership |
| Exchange decision |
One decision for all owners |
One decision per co-owner |
| Exchange agreement |
One, in the LLC’s name |
One per co-owner who exchanges |
| Tax reporting |
Form 1065 for the LLC |
The LLC’s Form 1065 for the year of the drop, Form 7217 for each partner and each co-owner‘s own return, with Form 8824 for each exchange |
Does distributing the property to the partners trigger tax?
No, distributing the property to the partners generally triggers no tax under Section 731, because a partner recognizes gain on a distribution only when the money received exceeds his or her basis in the partnership. Two exceptions matter in practice, namely property a partner contributed within the past seven years and a change in each partner’s share of the loan.
Under Sections 704(c)(1)(B) and 737, distributing contributed property within seven years of the contribution can make the contributing partner recognize the gain that existed when the property went in. Those rules do not reach a building the LLC bought with its own cash, but a building the LLC received in a 1031 exchange for property a partner contributed can carry the same seven-year exposure. Under Section 752(b), a decrease in a partner’s share of partnership debt counts as a cash distribution, so a drop that leaves a partner with less of the loan than before can create gain if that deemed cash exceeds the partner’s basis.
How long should tenants in common wait between the drop and the sale?
No statute, regulation or IRS safe harbor sets a waiting period between the drop and the sale. The IRS and state tax agencies test two things instead, whether each co-owner held the interest for investment and whether the partnership was the real seller. Practitioners generally advise dropping before the property is listed, and many prefer a year or more.
Congress considered a one-year holding requirement for exchanges in 1989 and left it out of the final law. The two-year figure investors often hear comes from the related party rule in Section 1031(f), which governs exchanges between related parties, not the drop.
The cases and rulings cited most often in drop and swap disputes are summarized below.
| Case or Ruling |
Forum and Year |
What Happened |
Result |
| Commissioner v. Court Holding Co. |
U.S. Supreme Court, 1945 |
A corporation negotiated a sale, then liquidated, and its shareholders closed it |
Sale treated as the corporation’s |
| United States v. Cumberland Public Service Co. |
U.S. Supreme Court, 1950 |
Shareholders received the assets in liquidation and made the sale themselves |
Sale treated as the shareholders’ |
| Rev. Rul. 77-337 |
IRS ruling, 1977 |
A shareholder received property in liquidation and exchanged it right away under a prearranged plan |
IRS position that the property was not held for investment |
| Bolker v. Commissioner |
9th Circuit, 1985 |
A shareholder received property in liquidation and exchanged it about three months later |
Exchange upheld |
| Magneson v. Commissioner |
9th Circuit, 1985 |
An investor exchanged, then contributed the new property to a partnership |
Exchange upheld |
| Mason v. Commissioner |
Tax Court memo, 1988 |
Two partners split their partnerships’ properties and exchanged undivided interests with each other |
Distribution and exchange respected, but debt relief and a note were taxed as boot and the deficiency was upheld |
| Chase v. Commissioner |
Tax Court, 1989 |
A deed to a partner and his wife, signed months earlier, was recorded once the sale was certain, and the partnership kept the rents and paid the costs |
Partnership treated as seller, exchange denied |
| Appeal of Mitchell |
California OTA, 2018 (non-precedential) |
The partnership signed the sale contract, and two minority partners took deeded interests days before closing under a plan known from the start |
Exchange upheld |
| Appeals of F.A.R. Investments |
California OTA, 2021 (precedential, 2022-OTA-395P) |
The entity negotiated and signed the purchase agreement, and the deeds went out days before closing |
Exchange denied |
| Matter of Hadar |
New York Division of Tax Appeals, 2025 (ALJ determination) |
A long-planned drop on the day of the sale, after the LLC signed the contract and assigned it to the co-owners, who closed as sellers and paid their share of the commission |
Exchange upheld |
Why does the purchase contract matter more than the calendar?
The purchase contract matters because it shows who negotiated the sale. Under the Court Holding doctrine, a sale the partnership negotiated can be treated as the partnership’s sale even if the partners hold title at closing. A drop made after the LLC signed a contract, on the same terms, is the pattern that failed in Chase and F.A.R. Investments.
The facts that helped taxpayers in Mitchell and Hadar were a plan to separate that predated the sale, real conveyances and co-owners who acted as sellers at closing. In both cases the entity had signed the sale contract before the drop, so a signed contract raises the risk without deciding the outcome, and neither decision is precedent.
The facts that hurt taxpayers in Chase and F.A.R. Investments were an entity that negotiated the sale and kept acting as the owner, co-owners who never took the rents or paid the costs, and deeds that changed little in practice. In F.A.R. Investments the entity also signed the purchase agreement as the sole seller, and the co-owners never signed a tenancy-in-common agreement. If the LLC has already signed a contract, review the alternatives later in this post with your attorney before attempting a drop.
Is a drop and swap riskier in California?
Yes, a drop and swap carries more risk in California, because practitioners report that the Franchise Tax Board audits these transactions more often than the IRS or other states, and the state’s precedential drop and swap decisions have gone against the taxpayers. California taxes capital gains at ordinary income rates, so the state tax at stake is large.
The two precedential decisions are Appeal of Brookfield Manor (1989) and F.A.R. Investments (2021), and the Franchise Tax Board won both. The Office of Tax Appeals sided with the taxpayer in Appeal of Mitchell (2018), but that opinion is not precedential, and the OTA declined to rely on it in F.A.R. Investments for that reason.
In Appeals of F.A.R. Investments (2022-OTA-395P), the OTA looked at who negotiated the sale, whether the former partners negotiated for themselves, how much time passed after the entity’s negotiations, whether the terms stayed the same and whether the co-owners took on the benefits and burdens of ownership. A New York administrative law judge reached the opposite result in Matter of Hadar (2025), rejecting the Division of Taxation’s argument for a minimum holding period, although under New York Tax Law Section 2010(5) such a determination is not precedent.
How do co-owners keep a tenancy in common from being treated as a partnership?
Co-owners keep a tenancy in common from being treated as a partnership by acting as co-owners of leased property, not as a business that divides profits. Treas. Reg. 301.7701-1(a)(2) says mere co-ownership of property that is maintained, repaired and rented is not a separate entity, while co-owners who provide services to occupants can be.
A single-tenant NNN property, where the tenant pays taxes, insurance and maintenance, fits the regulation’s description of rented property more naturally than an apartment building where the owners supply services. The co-owners’ conduct after the drop matters as much as the deed.
Rev. Proc. 2002-22 sets out 15 conditions under which the IRS will consider a ruling request that a tenancy in common is not a partnership. It is not a safe harbor, and the procedure itself says its guidelines are not substantive rules and are not to be used for audit purposes. Practitioners still use it as a benchmark, and section 6.03 warns that the IRS generally will not rule where the co-owners held the property through a partnership immediately before, which describes every drop.
The conditions that matter most after a drop are summarized below.
| Condition |
What Rev. Proc. 2002-22 Looks For |
Practical Step After the Drop |
| Tenancy in common title (6.01) |
Each owner holds title directly or through a disregarded entity |
Deed each interest to the member’s single-member LLC |
| No entity treatment (6.03) |
No partnership return, common business name or holding out as partners |
Report the property on each owner’s return, not a partnership return |
| Voting (6.05) |
Unanimous approval for sales, leases, blanket loans and hiring a manager |
Require unanimous consent for those decisions in the co-ownership agreement |
| Restrictions on alienation (6.06) |
Each owner may transfer, partition or encumber its interest |
Limit transfer restrictions to lender terms and a right of first offer |
| Proportionate sharing (6.08, 6.09) |
Revenue, costs and blanket debt shared by ownership percentage |
Pay rent and expenses through each owner’s account pro rata |
| No business activities (6.11) |
Customary repair and maintenance only |
Keep tenant services to what rent normally covers |
| Management agreements (6.12) |
Renewable at least annually, with no fee based on profits |
Sign a one-year renewable management agreement |
Can the LLC elect out of partnership status under Section 761(a)?
Yes, an LLC can elect out of partnership status under Section 761(a), but only in narrow cases. Every member must join, the members must own the property as co-owners for investment only, each must keep the right to take or sell its share, and no one may hold authority to buy or sell for more than a year.
A formal election is filed with the return for the first year the exclusion applies, and an election inferred from the owners’ conduct requires that intent from the first tax year, so it rarely rescues an LLC with years of partnership returns. When a valid election excludes the LLC from all of subchapter K, IRC Section 1031(e) treats each owner’s interest as an interest in the partnership’s assets rather than in a partnership. That makes the election a planning tool at purchase, set up under Treas. Reg. 1.761-2, rather than a fix at the time of sale.
What is a swap and drop, and when does it fit?
A swap and drop reverses the order. The partnership completes the 1031 exchange first, then later distributes tenancy-in-common interests in the replacement property, or the single-member LLCs that hold it, to its members. It fits partners who agree to exchange now but expect to separate later, not a partner who needs cash at the sale.
The cases usually cited run in the other direction, from co-ownership into an entity. Magneson upheld an exchange followed the same day by a contribution to a partnership, and California’s Board of Equalization, in its precedential Appeal of Rago Development Corp. (2015), upheld exchanges into tenancy-in-common interests that the owners held for seven months before contributing the property to an LLC, as their lender required.
The IRS has not withdrawn Rev. Rul. 75-292, which treats a transfer to a new corporation right after an exchange as fatal to the holding requirement. In a private letter ruling released in December 2024 (PLR 202449007), the IRS still applied that ruling and Rev. Rul. 77-337, distinguishing them only because the distribution in that case was forced by a trust’s termination rather than made under a voluntary, prearranged plan. Form 1065 Schedule B also asks whether the partnership distributed, during the year, replacement property it received in a like-kind exchange that year or the year before, so the distribution is visible.
Advisors who use the structure often recommend waiting a year or more before distributing. A later sale of the distributed interest raises the same intent questions as how soon you can sell 1031 replacement property. A swap and drop is also a different idea from “swap till you drop,” the informal name for exchanging until death.
What does the partner who cashes out actually owe?
The partner who cashes out owes tax on his or her share of the gain as if the property had been sold with no exchange. At top federal rates, that is up to 25 percent on the gain from past depreciation, up to 20 percent on the rest and 3.8 percent net investment income tax, plus any state tax.
The drop usually does not change the amount. When the drop liquidates a partner’s interest, Section 732(b) gives the deeded interest his or her basis in the LLC interest, which for partners who bought the building together normally matches their share of the LLC’s basis, and Section 735(b) adds the LLC’s holding period so the gain stays long term. What the drop changes is who bears the gain, since it lands on the partner who took the cash instead of being shared with the partner who stayed. The rates and thresholds behind these numbers are explained in our guide to capital gains tax on real estate.
The illustrative example below follows the two apartment partners from the opening scenario through a $4,000,000 sale, assuming the LLC bought the building (so no contributed-property rules apply), $200,000 of selling costs, an adjusted basis of $1,400,000 after $600,000 of straight-line depreciation, a $1,000,000 loan, a 50/50 split and top federal rates.
| Line Item |
Partner Who Takes Cash |
Partner Who Exchanges |
| Share of sale price |
$2,000,000 |
$2,000,000 |
| Share of selling costs |
$100,000 |
$100,000 |
| Share of adjusted basis |
$700,000 |
$700,000 |
| Share of realized gain |
$1,200,000 |
$1,200,000 |
| Gain from depreciation (unrecaptured Section 1250 gain) |
$300,000 |
$300,000 |
| Share of loan paid off at closing |
$500,000 |
$500,000 |
| Net proceeds |
$1,400,000 to the partner |
$1,400,000 to the intermediary |
| Federal tax at 25% on depreciation gain |
$75,000 |
Deferred |
| Federal tax at 20% on remaining gain |
$180,000 |
Deferred |
| Net investment income tax at 3.8% |
$45,600 |
Deferred |
| Federal tax due |
$300,600 |
$0 |
At top rates, the partner who takes cash keeps about $1,099,400 before state tax, and the federal bill comes to about 25 percent of his gain. Each rate in the table is a maximum, and a married couple with no other income would owe about $248,000 under 2026 brackets, because part of the $900,000 falls in the 15 percent bracket, part of the depreciation gain is taxed below 25 percent and the 3.8 percent tax reaches only income above $250,000.
How much NNN property must the exchanging partner buy to defer all of his gain?
The exchanging partner must buy replacement property costing at least his share of the net sale price, $1,900,000 in this example, reinvest all $1,400,000 of his proceeds and take on at least $500,000 of new debt or add the same amount in cash. Any shortfall is taxable to the extent of his gain.
In this example he buys an AutoZone property for $1,950,000 with his $1,400,000 of exchange funds and a $550,000 loan, which defers all $1,200,000 of his gain. His basis in the AutoZone is $750,000, which is the $700,000 he carried over plus $50,000 of net new debt. The steps for an exchange into NNN property apply to him as they would to any sole owner, including his own 45-day identification and 180-day closing deadlines.
His deferral can continue for decades under the approach Alan calls 1031 Until You Die, where serial exchanges end in a stepped-up basis for heirs.
What are the alternatives when partners want different things?
The main alternatives to a drop and swap are a swap and drop, redeeming only the departing partner with a deeded interest, a buyout before the sale, a partnership exchange with a special allocation of boot, and a buyer’s installment note passed to the departing partner. Each trades tax risk, complexity and the timing of the departing partner’s cash differently.
The comparison below shows what each option asks of the partners.
| Option |
How It Works |
When the Departing Partner Is Paid |
Main Risk |
| Drop and swap |
Every partner takes a deeded interest before the sale |
At closing |
Challenges over who sold and whether the interest was held for investment |
| Redeem only the departing partner |
The LLC deeds an undivided interest to the departing partner and exchanges its own share |
At closing |
The same who-sold question for the deeded share, and with only two partners the LLC becomes a disregarded entity, so the result matches a full drop |
| Swap and drop |
The LLC exchanges first and distributes interests later |
After a later sale of the distributed interest |
A prearranged distribution can be challenged, and the departing partner waits |
| Buyout before the sale |
The staying partner or the LLC buys the departing interest |
At the buyout |
The departing partner pays tax at the buyout, and the buyer needs the capital |
| Special allocation of boot |
The LLC exchanges and pays cash out, allocating that gain to the departing partner |
At closing |
The allocation must have substantial economic effect under Section 704(b) |
| Buyer’s installment note |
The intermediary receives part of the price as the buyer’s note, which goes to the departing partner |
As note payments arrive |
The buyer must agree, and payments depend on the buyer’s credit |
Can the exchanging partner use a DST or a reverse exchange instead?
Yes, the exchanging co-owner can buy Delaware Statutory Trust interests or use a reverse exchange, because after the drop he exchanges on his own. A DST suits a partner who wants a small, fully passive position, and a reverse exchange suits one who finds the right NNN property before the sale closes.
The trade-offs of a DST in control, fees and liquidity are laid out in our DST vs NNN comparison. In a reverse 1031 exchange, an exchange accommodation titleholder buys the NNN property first and holds it for up to 180 days while the co-owner’s interest sells.
What changes for the lender, title and tenant after a drop?
After a drop, the lender must approve the co-owners as owners or borrowers, the title company must insure each co-owner’s interest, and the tenants must be told to pay rent to the co-owners. Skipping any of these leaves evidence that the partnership still owned and ran the property, which undercuts the structure.
Four items need attention before the deeds record:
- The loan usually needs lender consent, and the lender may ask each co-owner to assume the loan.
- The title insurance should be reviewed with the title company, which may issue new policies or endorsements so that each co-owner’s single-member LLC is insured.
- The transfer and property tax treatment of a deed from an LLC to its members varies by state and county, so the co-owners should confirm it before the deeds record.
- The tenants should receive notice of the new owners and rent direction letters, and a NNN tenant should sign a new estoppel certificate naming the co-owners, because a buyer will ask for one.
How should co-investors take title so they never need a drop and swap?
Co-investors avoid a future drop and swap by taking title at purchase as tenants in common, each through his or her own single-member LLC, under a written co-ownership agreement. Each owner is then a separate taxpayer from the first day and can sell, exchange or hold its share without restructuring anything.
Alan Fruitman makes the same recommendation in Chapter 6, 1031 Exchange, of The NNN Triple Net Property Book, writing, “If you purchase an investment property with a friend(s) or relative(s), it may be advisable for each investor to have his or her own LLC and to take title as Tenants-in-Common.” He adds that talking with your attorney and CPA about ownership entities before you buy is an upfront cost that is money well spent. Choosing those advisors early is part of building your 1031 exchange team.
The same planning applies to siblings who expect to co-own property after a parent’s death. Heirs inheriting NNN property through an LLC or partnership receive an interest that cannot be exchanged, while heirs who inherit deeded interests can each choose their own path.
What should a tenancy-in-common agreement for NNN property cover?
A tenancy-in-common agreement for NNN property should cover how decisions are made, how income and expenses are split, what happens when one owner wants to sell and how the owners resolve deadlock. It should read as a co-ownership agreement rather than an operating agreement, so that it does not recreate the partnership.
The provisions that matter most are these:
- Any sale, new lease, lease amendment, blanket loan or management contract requires unanimous approval.
- Rent and expenses are shared in proportion to ownership and paid through each owner’s account.
- An owner who wants to sell first offers its interest to the other owners at fair market value.
- A buy-sell or appraisal process resolves deadlock before any owner asks a court to partition the property.
- Any management agreement runs for one year and renews annually.
When is a drop and swap the wrong tool?
A drop and swap is the wrong tool when the gain is small relative to the legal and lender costs, the LLC has already signed a purchase contract, a partner contributed the property within seven years, or the owner is a corporation. In those cases, a buyout, an installment note or a taxable sale is usually the cleaner route.
Each of these situations points somewhere else:
- A small gain may not justify an attorney, a CPA, new deeds and lender fees, and paying the tax can be the better trade.
- A signed contract in the LLC’s name puts the deal in the Court Holding fact pattern, so the partners should consider a buyout, an installment note or a special allocation instead.
- Contributed property distributed within seven years can trigger the contributing partner’s built-in gain.
- A corporation, including an S corporation, recognizes gain when it distributes appreciated property, so the drop itself is taxable.
- Partners who no longer trust each other may struggle as tenants in common, because every major decision needs both signatures until the sale closes.
Most of the failures behind these warnings happen before the sale closes, the same stage where the common 1031 exchange mistakes occur. Settle the structure first, then list the property.
About the Author
Alan Fruitman is the founder of 1031tax.com and President & Managing Broker of Real Estate Foundation, Inc. Alan began his real estate career in 1993 and has closed more than 1,000 properties valued at several billion dollars. He is the author of The NNN Triple Net Property Book and is a nationally recognized authority on single tenant net leased property and IRC Section 1031 exchanges. With more than 30 years of experience, Alan advises investors on identifying, underwriting, and acquiring absolute NNN leased assets with corporate guarantees, including banks, quick service restaurants, pharmacies, dollar stores, convenience stores, and auto related retailers. Alan holds Colorado real estate license ER1322889 and helps buyers and sellers nationwide.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, financial, or real estate advice. Every exchange and tax situation is unique. We strongly encourage you to work with qualified professionals, including a qualified intermediary, CPA, and real estate attorney, before making any decisions related to a 1031 exchange. 1031tax.com is a service of Real Estate Foundation, Inc.